Why Francona Had to Be the Fall Guy
After nearly a week of digesting the chaos that went down on Yawkey Way with the Red Sox, I've come to the conclusion Terry Francona had to go. This is not to say Francona (Tito) was the sole reason for the Red Sox collapse or that he was even mostly to blame. No. This goes back to the adage we've heard so often in sports: you can't get rid of the players, so you get rid of the coach.
Terry Francona's list of accomplishments makes him the greatest manager in Red Sox history. His two World Series wins ('04, '07) ties him with Bill Carrigan (1915, 1916) for most in franchise history. In his 8 years on the Sox bench he's managed 45 playoff games, most in team history. He was an integral part of the revival of Red Sox nation. After Aaron Boone ripped the hearts out of Red Sox nation in 2003 with a walk off home run in game 7 of the ALCS changes were needed. Out went Grady Little and in came Francona. That signified a new era at Fenway.
In his first season as manager Francona guided the Red Sox to their first World Series title in 86 years. He brought another title to Yawkey Way in 2007. His legacy had been cemented. But for everything Francona had done for the organization, there's no denying he failed the 2011 version of the Red Sox. This was the team that was supposed to win 100 games; score 900 runs; and boasted what many thought was the best starting rotation in the American League. The Boston Herald even stated about the 2011 version of the Sox, "This could be Sox best team ever." Expectations were high, and rightfully so. The team had acquired an MVP caliber player in Adrian Gonzalez. Carl Crawford was signed as a free agent after so many years of victimizing the Sox on the base paths as a member of the Tampa Bay Rays. With a payroll of more than $160 million anything short of a deep playoff run would be considered a failure. But this Red Sox season was worse than a failure. It turned out to be historically embarrassing.
Despite a slow start the Sox did nothing but fuel expectations they were the team to beat in the American League. During a 4 1/2 month stretch the Sox had played the best ball in the majors going 81-42 from mid-April to the end of August. Entering September the team had a half game lead over the Yankees in the division, and at the time, the Rays were an afterthought. A full 9 games behind the Red Sox. But then the September that no Red Sox fan will ever forget commenced. The team went 7-20 over the final month of the season. That 9 game lead over the Rays disappeared. In its place, the worst collapse in Major League Baseball history. The much ballyhooed Boston starting rotation was in shambles, finishing with an era of 7.08 for the month of September. The Sox were sinking in quicksand and there was no way to rescue them. The final blow came the night of September 28th, the final day of the regular season, when the Orioles completed a comeback win over Boston and the Rays wrapped up the wild card spot with an Evan Longoria walk-off home run against the Yankees. The collapse was complete and ultimately someone had to pay.
Here's why that someone had to be Terry Francona. During his exit press conference Francona said, "When things started to go, I wanted desperately for our guys to care about each other on the field. I wasn't seeing that as much as I wanted to. I tried to help make that better, the coaches also, it just wasn't ever comfortable. You've heard me talk all the time about going in one direction and getting through challenges and meeting them together, but I just didn't think we were doing that. That's my responsibility to get them to do that and it wasn't happening to my satisfaction." By Francona's own account, what he was doing was not getting through to the players. As Manager it's his job to get the players to respond. Even when the team was winning Francona admitted there were concerns. He cited a team meeting they had after a 14-0 win in Toronto September 6. He knew the team had issues behind the scenes but he was unable to squash those issues. They continued to be a problem, even at a time when the Red Sox should have been dialed in on a playoff run. Reports have surfaced that members of the starting rotation were drinking beer in the clubhouse on their off days and that it's been going on for two years. Not one Red Sox player or official has denied that. That explains why Josh Beckett and Jon Lester appeared gassed the final month of the season, and why questions about their conditioning are valid.
In the end Francona knew there was a problem in the clubhouse. He attempted to fix it and the players tuned him out. He said as much in his exit press conference, "I felt frustrated with my inability to reach guys I had reached in the past and that bothers me.”
While Francona had some great years in Boston it was obvious he had lost his team and the time had come for him to go.




